Monday, June 26, 2023

Alaska Redistricting Board Agrees To Pay $115,000 For Girdwood Plaintiffs Legal Fees

 My notes of the meeting (It was short and sweet.)

12:29 - voices - Melanie, Matt, Peter chatting about weather - Sunny in Nome, not Anchorage

John:  You there?  Let's wait a couple of minutes.  

Peter:  Budd?  Yes, I'm here.  Waiting for one more member.  

12:33  Take roll: Bahnke, Binkley, Borromeo, Marcum, Simpson - all here

Binkley:  We have one item, unless any proposed amendments.  Adopt Amendment.  Seconded.  Adopted

Matt Singer:  Wrapping up legal challenges to plan adopted by the Board.  At Board's direction, negotiated with Girdwood plaintiffs = $115,000 30% discount.  If party prevails on successful constitutional claim.  Their offer in zone of reasonable.  Encourage the Board to accept.

Simpson:  Does not create a precedent for others, by agreeing to stipulated amount here, doesn't tie us into other claims.

Singer:  attribute 25% to Supreme court and 75% to Superior Court.  Reduce this to court order.  Does not tie Board's hand on other issue that remain in litigation.  

Binkley:  Motion to accept offer by Girdwood plaintiffs.  Moved, seconded, no objections.

Motion adopted.  Settled with Girdwood plaintiffs.  Thanks for their reasonableness in this.  appreciate their participation.  Other comments.

Bahnke:  Echo you.  If citizens hadn't taken the steps they took, this wouldn't have ended up as it did.  

Binkley:  Thanks.  Motion for adjournment?  No objections.

12:40pm adjourned.   

[UPDATE:  I'd just note that at this meeting they mentioned not seeing a precedent for payments to other plaintiffs.  That means there are other outstanding request(s) for reimbursement.  The most likely are the East Anchorage plaintiffs because they also won a constitutional claim.  So this may not have been the final meeting.]

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments will be reviewed, not for content (except ads), but for style. Comments with personal insults, rambling tirades, and significant repetition will be deleted. Ads disguised as comments, unless closely related to the post and of value to readers (my call) will be deleted. Click here to learn to put links in your comment.