Writing about Zohran Mamdani has been on my todo list for a while. I'm finally getting around to it on election night.
As I begin writing, NPR has declared Mikie Sherrill the winner of the New Jersey governor's race (with 57% of the vote) and Abigail Spanberger the winner of the Virginia governor's race (56%), but they haven't declared a winner in the New York mayor's race. Mamdani is ahead with 49% of the vote followed by Cuomo with 41% of the vote, with 60% of the votes counted.
Who is Mamdani? Mamdani is a special candidate. He's articulate, quick witted, innovative, funny, and has great charisma.
He was born in Uganda. His dad is a Muslim Indian from Gujarati. He also happens to be a university professor at Columbia. His mom, a Hindu Indian, and a Harvard graduate, is the world renowned film maker Mira Nair. His family moved to South Africa and then, when Mamdani was seven, to the United States.
His was a relatively privileged childhood - though he was a dark skinned male in racist USA. I imagine he met a lot of very interesting people around the family dinner table. He graduated from Bowdoin College and before running for office, was a hip hop artist. (All this from Wikipedia.)
Given his African and Indian roots and family's achievements, I reckon that his world view is much bigger and more inclusive than most USians.
Why has the winner of the Democratic primary been so attacked, to the extent that the loser in that primary, Andrew Cuomo has run as an independent in today's general election?
Basically he's been attacked with several of the GOP 'epithets. Words that most people couldn't accurately define, but just know they mean the person is a terrible person. Let's look at them:
- Muslim
- Socialist
- Progressive
He's also been called 'anti-Semetic' based, apparently, on the fact that he's Muslim and has publicly said that Israel is carrying out genocide in Gaza. It's hard to distinguish what people say he has said from what he has actually said. When I googled 'what has Mamdani said about Gaza?' many, if not most, of the sites that came up were Israeli media.
Muslim in GOP dialect means 'terrorist', non-Christian, anti-Semite
Socialist means the same as Communist to the target audience and it means bad things. Not sure what the people who get riled up over these terms think they mean. But something anti-capitalist and anti-personal freedoms, and clearly anti-American..
Progressive, as Trump uses it, means anti-American, pro-trans, and anti-white.
The basic things that Mamdani has campaigned on, as I understand it watching from Alaska, are making New York housing more affordable in part with a rent freeze, free transit and child care, and taxing the very rich to help pay for it.
So who is the opposition? This would seem pretty obvious
- the very rich see him as a threat
- landlords (often part of the very rich) don't want anyone who wants to keep rents "affordable'
- people who are strongly pro-Israel
- establishment Democrats
When we first came to Anchorage we went to a couple of AIPAC presentations. I was very impressed by how well organized, how well spoken, and how prepared they were with every detail of their presentation. But it was also clear that they were very hardline pro-Israel. If anyone had an even slightly critical question about Israel, it was politely, authoritatively and firmly answered, There was no acknowledgement that things might not be perfect. In response to AIPACs hard line, another less rigid Israeli lobbying group - J-Street formed.
We saw after the primary that New York Democratic politicians were reluctant to endorse Mamdani. In part, probably in large part, AIPAC (American Israel Public Affairs Committee) was lobbying politicians strongly - like House Minority leader Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, whose district is in New York - NOT to endorse Mamdani.
Jeffries only endorsed Mamdani on October 24, less than two weeks before the election.
Another factor that some have pointed out, is that older Democratic leadership, have gotten set in their ways - their policy positions, how they interact with Republicans, the the perks of office. But a younger, less white, less male cadre of politicians believe their stands on some issues are out of date and week; and their genteel behavior are no match for the ruthlessness of the Republicans. People like AOC and now Mamdani challenge their seniority and everything else.
Making Mamdani seem like an enemy of Israel matters in New York because it has the largest Jewish population in the US. There are conservative Jews who are strongly pro-Israel no matter what. But probably more Jews are concerned about how Israel has killed so many Palestinians and are strongly opposed to Netanyahu.
In Mamdani's case, electing a Muslim, means, it would seem, to AIPAC electing a politician they can't control.
But not every Muslim fits the GOP stereotype. Certainly not Mamdani. He's taken his life experiences and charm and created a monster volunteer group to get out the vote. He doesn't back down at charges of being progressive. But he does all that with his charming smile.
As I finish this post, Mamdani has not been declared the winner with 50.4% of the vote to Cuomo's 41.6%
He's going to have a lot of powerful people still fighting his agenda. But he's surprised the establishment - both the party establishment and the New York establishment with his unique and successful campaign for mayor. Let's see if he can keep that organization going and and make New York City a more affordable place to live.
I think he's the future of the party, but the old guard won't just roll over.