Showing posts with label elections 2026. Show all posts
Showing posts with label elections 2026. Show all posts

Sunday, November 15, 2026

“when elected, be an Inhabitant of that State for which he shall be chosen.”

Eric Hafner is a prisoner in New York State   He has never been in Alaska  Yet he’s on the ballot in Alaska as a candidate for the US House of Representatives  As a Democrat.  The only one of the four candidates with a D after his name.  

Two years ago, when he ran, the Democrats filed a lawsuit to get him off the ballot on the grounds that he was in prison in New York and not an Alaskan inhabitant, nor would he be.  The Republicans fought them in court to keep his name on the ballot.  

The Alaska Supreme Court citing the qualifications listed in the United States Constitution, 

No Person shall be a Senator who shall not have attained to the Age of thirty Years, and been nine Years a Citizen of the United States, and who shall not, when elected, be an Inhabitant of that State for which he shall be chosen. [U.S. Constitution, Article I, section 3, clause 3]

ruled that there was always the possibility he could get released by the election. 

It’s 2026 and he’s back on the ballot and he’s still in prison in New York as far as anyone knows. He’s not appeared in Alaska. He’s not an inhabitant of the state. 

As of Friday night he had 21,057 votes. More than the difference between the leading candidate, incumbent Nick Begich and second place candidate non-partisan Bill Hill. 

From Division of Elections update 11/13/26


The NYT, The National Republican Party, and the President of the United States have all complained about long time Alaska resident Daniel J. Sullivan being on the ballot for US Senate to confuse voters because his name is similar to Senator Dan Sullivan. The DOJ has filed suit against him. Even though there is no law against having the same name as another candidate, or against recruiting candidates.

As of Friday night Daniel J. had only 4,560 votes. Less than half the difference (10,412 votes).between front runner Democrat Mary Peltola and second place candidate Sen. Dan Sullivan.


The NYT did not investigate Hafner as a spoiler candidate or those folks spending spending several hundred thousand dollars promoting him in hopes of diverting voters away from Bill Hill.  Even though he's much closer to them than Daniel J.  

My gut reaction is that now is the time to acknowledge that Hafner is not present in Alaska for his (non) election and have him thrown off the ballot.  

But one's gut is often wrong.  

If that were to happen now how would the State handle his votes?  Would his votes evaporate and Begich's percent of the votes would increase?   My quick math says Begich would have 52% of the vote and win.  Would they distribute his second place votes?  

Alaska has ranked choice voting, so it makes more sense to see where Hafner's second place votes would go.  But I don't now how to 'read' the files the Division of Elections offers with all the data. (My computer says it can't open the JSON file. And if I could it would probably take forever to figure out how to get what I wanted.)  

However, Fair Vote seems to have figured it out and calculated how the next rounds will go:


By subtracting the 4th round votes for Begich and Hill from their 3rd round votes, you can figure out how many second place Hafner votes went (actually, will go)  to each candidate:

Begich gets 1,468 votes from Hafner

Hill gets 9,901 votes from Hafner

And about 11,000 voters either ranked people who were already eliminated, or no one at all.

My guess would be that the people who voted Begich as their second choice leaned right, but didn't really want to vote Begich first.  (Yes, I know there are probably lots of other interpretations.)

At this point, if FairVote got it right, there's nothing left to do except congratulate Begich.  

But it raises two big unresolved issues for me:

1.  Embracing Ranked Choice Voting.  Proposition 2 that would have ended ranked choice voting (and open primaries and some campaign finance disclosures) is going down to defeat in this year's election.  It's time that Democratic Party learn how to live with it and even embrace it.  What if the left leaning organizations (including the Democratic Party) that anointed the non-partisan Bill Hill as their candidate and steered their money to him, had been move even handed and also supported Democrat Matt Schultz?  How much did the lack of a legit candidate with a D following his name give the edge to Begich?  The Democrats need to lean into RCV more and to trust the voters.  In this election they should have trusted both left leaning candidates, Hill and Democrat Shultz.  Before Schultz dropped out due to lack of money and support, the two had said they would run cooperative campaigns and ask their supporters to choose the other as their second choice.  That's how ranked choice voting is supposed to work.

I don't know that Begich would have lost, but I think there would have been more enthusiasm and even more voters if that had happened. 

2.  More obstacles to out of state candidates   Alaska needs to find some ways to make it more difficult for out of state people to run in Alaska as a lark.  When the US Constitution (which lists the qualifications for House and Senate candidates) was written, there were relatively few states and they were close together (though travel from state to state took much longer than it does today.) 

Right now it costs $100 to file to run for US Senate or House in Alaska.  Some have suggested raising the filing fee and/or require a minimum number of signatures.  Or have the Division of Elections put on the ballot the state of residence after the name of someone who is not an Alaska resident when the ballots are printed.  


[One last note: I did most of this Saturday (yesterday) morning.  There was an update on the vote count Saturday afternoon.  Things continue in the same direction, so I'm not changing the images  If you want to see the latest unofficial numbers, click here.]

Friday, October 30, 2026

Treefall, Absentee Ballot Review [UPDATED]

 Woke up to the sound of high winds - wasn't sure at first if it was winds or planes.  But it was wind.  And a spruce tree we'd planted 40+ years ago, toppled over and is resting on the corner of our neighbor's roof.  The tree was on a hill, like the one that fell over last winter.  So the downside roots have less to grip.  Last year the tree fell into another tree which stopped it from falling further. When the top, that was leaning onto the other tree was cut off,  the tree stayed standing at about a 50˚ angle.  The tree man who came out to look today said he thought the tree today would have come down slowly.  



Tuesday I was at the Division of Elections to observe the the DoE employees as they reviewed the incoming absentee ballots.  Two workers sit at a small table.  They get a plastic bin with ballots in it.  They are sorted by date received and district.  They get a slip of paper with info on it - district, date received, number of electronic ballots and mailed in ballots, total number, and sequence numbers.  Another paper has a list of the voters with the information on the voter.  Then they count the ballots to make sure the numbers are right.  Next, they check the information the voter has put on the ballot against their list - name, address, id number, etc.  

photo from ADN* - no phones
allowed when observing

I was there just half a day because there were too many observers, so I split the day with another observer.  Half a day was plenty.  The two workers I observed Tuesday were terrific.  They welcomed me to the table and said they'd answer any question I had, but not to talk while they were counting ballots.  They went through the ballots really fast.  The bins had anywhere from half a dozen ballots to one with 324 ballots.  

There were very few ballots that were flagged with problems.  Two, from a married couple, had been written on the wrong envelopes.  He was listed on her envelope and vice versa.  The reviewers were able to get permission from a supervisor to accept those ballots.  Another two people from the same address didn't have witnesses.  They were rejected.  Someone else had used a primary election envelope and that too was rejected.  (I asked the next day if anyone had checked to see if the person had possibly used the correct ballot, but the wrong envelope.  They assured me someone had checked.)   Other voters had moved and were in new districts but used the old district ballots.  So their choices for state offices (based on their district) would not count because they no longer lived in that district, but the statewide offices - Governor, US House and Senate and some or all of the judges (depending on which judicial districts they lived in) would count.  

Wednesday, I observed a different pair of workers, but they were equally friendly and efficient.  But this time they encouraged me to get a copy of the register they were reviewing.  At first I was confused.  When they read off the identifier number (drivers license, social security (last four digits ok), voter id, or date of birth I couldn't find them on my register.  I asked and was told it wasn't on my copy - confidential information.  

The first day, without my own register, I watched the envelopes carefully,  Some had one forever stamp, some had two, others had no stamps. One had a stamped price from the post office.  $1.11.  That's more than a forever stamp.  So I asked.  Turns out, the post office will deliver them without stamps.

[There's been the sound of chain saws in the neighborhood most of the day, and just now it sounded closer.  They're working on our tree now too.]

One of the things I realized was that the ballots had already been reviewed once.  People had collected them, taken off the privacy cover, reviewed the information, marked some for rejection, and resealed them.  

Let me explain that a bit more.  I don't have a photo of back of the envelope because I didn't take a picture of ours and we had to leave our phones outside the room we were observing in.  


[UPDATED Nov 1, 2026:  I've talked to folks and found my memory faulty because they say the ballot, in the secrecy sleeve, is inside a sealed envelope before being put into the mailing envelope.  While such a seal can be opened, it's much harder and probably not feasible to do in any number.  So, my concern about a ballot being easily accessible, is much reduced.  There is, though, still seems to be a step that is unobserved, which makes the show of having observers seem a bit odd.]

This is my drawing of the flap on the back of the envelope.  The ballot is put inside the envelope and on the back, the voter writes their information and the witness signature.  Then the flap is pulled down, the adhesive at the bottom inside the flap is licked and sealed, covering all the information.  


The envelopes the people I observed worked with, had that privacy cover taken off [below] and it was resealed with the adhesive near the top of the flap.  I did look at one such envelope that someone had [in the review room so I didn't have my phone to take a picture] because they hadn't voted yet.  There was no perforation to help tear the flap off.  And some of the ballots had been torn off roughly.  Several the workers had to use tape to seal them better.  
So why am I bringing this up?  It seems to me that the whole point of allowing observers to watch the process of reviewing the ballots is to give confidence to the public that everything is on the up and up.  
But apparently, there's a whole process where the flaps are taken off, and the envelopes are unsealed with the ballots inside, before they are resealed.  And then the first round of checking the envelopes takes place.  All that happens, as far as I can tell, without independent observers watching.  

As I said, the people reviewing the ballots were absolutely professional AND welcoming to the observers (at least the four people I watched were to me.)  But behind closed doors, there are people with envelopes that are NOT sealed for a while.  It's a time when someone could slip out a ballot and add marks to the ranked choice ballots that would invalidate the ballot, at least for that race.  

Wednesday, I came in at noon and they were out of ballots at 2:30pm so I got to go home early.  Thursday's review was also cancelled and  Friday was too.  I'm not sure why.  

[The tree was cut while I wrote this and is gone now.  Cutting a tree takes less time than writing a blog post.]

*ADN = Anchorage Daily News

Friday, October 23, 2026

DOJ's Suit To Invalidate Alaska Election If Daniel S. Sullivan Doesn't Win [UPDATED] [UPDATED #2]

UPDATE 10/27/26: 

"State of Alaska says DOJ lawsuit over Senate race ‘has no legal basis’

Alaska Public Media | By Liz Ruskin

Published October 27, 2026 at 10:37 AM AKDT

Alaska Public Media

Alaska Elections Director Carol Beecher at a legislative hearing on July 22, 2026.

The State of Alaska is urging a federal judge to “immediately” dismiss a Trump administration lawsuit that could block certification of the U.S. Senate election if Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan narrowly loses.

“Delaying certification of Alaska’s election results—but only if a particular candidate does not win—would interfere with state election administration and threaten election integrity,” the Alaska Department of Law, representing the Division of Elections and director Carol Beecher, wrote in response to the lawsuit.

The state said the lawsuit “has no legal basis” and would sow distrust in the vote. . ."

From:  https://alaskapublic.org/news/politics/elections/2026-10-27/state-of-alaska-says-doj-lawsuit-over-senate-race-has-no-legal-basis  

This was not something I expected!  Very positive move.  I guess they know it will only interfere with getting election results out in a timely manner. 

Also, commenter Allen gives the link to find the court docket for Alaska court case that began last June.  Thanks, Allen.  This new case is a Federal, not State case.]]





UPDATE 10/24/26:  

"Under representation from the ACLU of Alaska, the League of Women Voters of Alaska joined two individual Alaskan voters and Common Cause in a filing to intervene on the case on Friday, October 23. If granted, an intervention allows these additional interested parties to join the existing suit to present our unique perspectives. We also filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, which would be considered by the court after the decision on the motion to intervene."] From an email from League of Women Voters


 This is getting lots of national and international attention already and I don't need to repeat more than the basics. Here's the start of The Guardian article:

"Donald Trump said he ordered the justice department to file a lawsuit to block the certification of Alaska’s US Senate results if the Republican incumbent loses, a move that voting rights experts called an “unprecedented intervention” by the federal government with control of Congress in the balance.

“I’m the one that said do it,” Trump told reporters as he landed in Florida for a campaign rally on Friday."

Some others:

CNBC

Newsweek

(Several others had paywalls so I won't link them, but you get the picture.  This is big news.  The first actual salvo of the Trump administration's attempt to overturn elections that don't go his way.)

Basically DOJ has filed suit to invalidate the Alaska Senate election if the sitting Republican Senator Daniel S. Sullivan doesn't win the election on the grounds that another candidate, named Daniel J. Sullivan, will have confused voters into voting for him instead of Daniel S. Sullivan.  (I'd note that I wasn't confused after I marked Daniel J. Sullivan as my second choice - my first choice was NOT Daniel S) (Because we have Ranked Choice Voting I can make a second and third choice when I vote.  You can even make a fourth choice vote, but I haven't figured out how that would ever matter because one of the candidates would have a majority before it got that far.)


What I can provide are links to nine blog posts I wrote in June and July of this year, where this battle was already fought out in the Alaska Courts and the Alaska Supreme Court ruled the State could not throw Daniel J. Sullivan off the ballot.  


I'd also note a couple of other points I didn't see much in the other coverage:

1.  The GOP have pushed hard* to get Democrats to vote for Eric Hafner for US Representative instead of Independent Bill Hill.  Hafner is a resident of a New York prison.  

*"Pushed hard" = sending out millions of dollars worth of flyers and other advertising to push Hafner and other non viable candidates to take votes from leading Democratic candidates. 

2.  The Alaska Division of Elections initially chose to drop Daniel J. Sullivan on the grounds that he was trying to confuse the voters (not a legal criterion of keeping someone off the ballot).  There is a good chance that the Republican led State and State Division of Elections won't challenge the DOJ lawsuit and simply invalidate the election.  What happens then?


Here are the posts I did in June and July of this year, chronicling how the State tried to keep Daniel J. Sullivan off the ballot and how the Alaska Supreme Court rejected that move.  

Tuesday, July 07, 2026  Silence [UPDATE: Ballots Printed And Overseas Ballots Sent]


I've already thrown out the flyers supporting Hafner, but I do have one that is in response to those flyers:  


My sense is the Republicans are sure the Democrats have put up Daniel J. Sullivan to run for Senate to confuse voters, because that's what they would do. And are doing with other candidates.  During the primaries they spent close to a million dollars promoting Outside (of Alaska) candidates like Hafner.  


Tuesday, October 20, 2026

The Ruckus Room, No Kings, Voting

 




Saturday was No Kings Day again.  But in Anchorage the energy has been dispersed in many directions.  I joined the car parade that StandUp Alaska organized.  Cars with "Vote" messages all over paraded through Mountain View, Fairview, and Government Hill.  








There was also a bicycle component.


Meanwhile the League of Women Voters had a Democracy Fair at the main library.  Democrats had people going door to door to urge people to vote for their candidates.  Others waved signs at a busy intersection  



The car and bike paraders ended up at the Ruckus Room which I'd never heard of.  It's in a closed dispensary that was renovated for over a year and now has some spaces for rent for community activities.  

It's at 2612 Eagle - between Northern Lights and Fireweed.  

I was impressed with this Tolkien vibe door, and the decor in general.  

It's a clean and interesting space if you have relatively small events.  There are even several very small rooms.  



The owner and operator of the Ruckus Room is Shel Weitzman.  



Blogger notes:  This blog has been competing for my time with life. I feel the pressure of the Óle writing group for something new each week.  And time seems to go by so fast.  Maybe that's a facet of getting older - a year is a much smaller fraction of my life than it was 50 years ago.  A week goes by like nothing  So, I wanted to write about No Kings and also about the Ruckus Room because the space there is cool and people should know about it.  No Kings gets plenty of coverage, but I had never heard of the Ruckus Room until Saturday.  And Shel appears to be a warm and interesting person.  I'm sure he's got a lot of interesting stories.  He did, for example, mention that his teenage sons helped with the remodeling.  And most posts take longer to write than it might appear.  Especially when I add a video in.  

My school volunteering has been limited this fall.  Monday mornings at the Rilke Schule and we haven't worked out time yet at Tudor (with the teacher I've worked with before Lake Otis was dissolved.)

And I'm signed up to be a poll worker and also to be an observer when the Division of Elections goes through the absentee and then the questioned ballots.  Which got me to drop off our absentee ballots on the first day - yesterday, October 19 - at the Division of Elections and then go see how the first day of voting was going at the Mid-town Mall (formerly the Sears Mall).  

There was a long line!


The second picture was taken from the red star looking back to the entrance to the polling place, but also including the alcove that goes to an entrance to the mall and where the line looped and comes out back into the mall.

The third photo is also from about the red star in the first picture and looks at the alcove and back out at the line going off into the distance in the mall.  

And there was about an inch of snow outside this morning - the first of the season!

And tomorrow and Thursday is the AFN (Alaska Federation of Natives) Convention.

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

Trump's Supposed To Be In Alaska Today [Updated]

 It's after 4pm.  He was supposed to speak at 3.  I can imagine them trying to get him to the arena and then to the stage.  Kalshi doesn't seem to have bets on the time, but they do on the subjects:

Screen shot:


 A lotta white faces waiting for him.  YouTube is covering it:



[The video is still available after it was over.  Trump starts about 2 hours 16 minutes.]

I don't think it will help Dan Sullivan. Not sure what's going to happen in the US House race. I'm guessing the incumbent Nick Begich is ahead. But there is a lot of campaign activity going on. Lots of Outside money flooding the airwaves and mailboxes with nasty lies about candidates.  

There are also supposed to be protesters outside the arena in Wasilla. Here's a picture from folks protesting at Church and Parks Highway.

[UPDATE 6:25pm:  Trump took the podium, about 4:35pm.  He spoke for over 90 minutes.  He seemed to be on task at the beginning - pushing voting for Dan Sullivan "not the fake Dan Sullivan" and Nick Begich.  He also endorsed Bernadette Wilson for Governor and said the other two Republicans should drop out.  He also told people to vote yes on Prop. 2 to get rid of ranked choice voting.  

He told countless lies about how everything in the United States is twenty times better than in all of history because of Trump.  He was typically derisive about Mary Peltola and Bill Hill.  It was unclear how many people were in the arena because the camera was focused on the podium.  

He also promised every voter $5000 if the House and Senate stay Republican.  That would seem like a blatant bribe, but if Congress stays Republican he doesn't have to worry about that.  If they change to Democratic, he needs to start worrying about being accountable.

He also raised some of the current GOP talking points about Democrats being Communists, about them being a threat of cutting school kids up to change their gender, and men in women's sports.  

I find it a little ironic that he had two Black (what I assume were) Secret Service men, and that the music at the end was the gay anthem,  YMCA.  Though I guess that's a song Trump heard a lot in the 1970s when he was a regular at NY City disco clubs.]











Saturday, October 10, 2026

Some Things Still Work: Ballot Arrived Today





Despite all that's been written about how the post office is/might hold up mail-in ballots, today (10/9/26) our ballots arrived.

The US Senate race is showing in the picture.  For those of you who don't have ranked choice voting, you can see what the RCV ballot looks like.    











Yesterday (10/9/26) according to the Alaska Division of Elections website, the ballots were mailed.  


One day!


If Trump's team isn't planning to delay ballots, they're at least doing a good job of getting Democrats to believe they will and to spend a lot of time getting ready to counter any such moves.  


At least in our household's case, things worked well.  


 

Thursday, September 24, 2026

Responding to Anon on Ranked Choice Voting

Anonymous commented on a  previous post about Ranked Choice Voting (RCV).  They  raised common issues  about RCV.  I decided it was easier, if I responded in a new post.  This is it.

To make it as clear as possible for the reader to distinguish between us, my comments are in BLUE and the commenter's comments are RED  


"These are things to consider when you are waxing poetic about RCV:"  

From US Dictionary:   

"The idiom "waxing poetic" describes the action of speaking or writing in an increasingly enthusiastic or eloquent manner. Often, this phrase is used when someone starts using a more florid or poetic language than might be expected or necessary."

This was a pretty fact based blog post.  Not particularly enthusiastic for ranked choice nor particularly florid.  I did speak positively about open primaries, saying they led to bi-partisan majorities in the legislature.  The basic tone is a fairly muted support of RCV as in this quote:

"There is no perfect system.  Whatever system you have, people figure out ways to game the system.  Ideally, we will not get rid of Ranked Choice Voting in November and we can learn how to make it work."


"Ballot Exhaustion" & Disenfranchisement: In RCV, if all the candidates you ranked are eliminated in early rounds, your ballot is marked as "exhausted" and discarded before the final tally. Consequently, the winner often claims a "majority" only of the remaining active ballots, not a true majority of all voters who cast a ballot. 

You don't necessarily get a majority in any non-RCV election if it's a three or four way race, say  if there is a Republican, a Democrat, and an Independent on the ballot.  In most elections, the one with the most votes - not a necessarily a majority - wins.  The Anchorage Municipal election for mayor partially addresses this by requiring a runoff if no one gets at least 45% of the vote.  

At least in RCV you get to pick a second and third choice - meaning if your first choice candidate doesn't win, you get a chance to vote for a second choice candidate.  That doesn't happen in the old system.  In that system, if your first choice doesn't win, your vote is essentially exhausted too.  



⁠The "Center-Squeeze" & Non-Monotonicity*: RCV can produce bizarre mathematical anomalies where gaining support can cause a candidate to lose, or losing support can cause them to win. A moderate candidate who is the acceptable second choice for almost everyone can get eliminated in the first round simply because they lacked enough intense first-place votes, leaving two polarizing extremes.

First, I agree, that it's possible for someone to be everyone's second choice, but they wouldn't get onto the general election ballot because they didn't get enough first place votes.  Probably not likely, but possible.  But with closed primaries, that candidate probably wouldn't make it to the general election. If you had three candidates on the general ballot under the old system, I don't know that the hypothetical moderate would win either  and we wouldn't ever know they were everyone's second choice. 

Complexity & Higher Error Rates: Ranking multiple candidates increases the cognitive load on voters and leads to higher rates of spoiled ballots (e.g., unintentionally ranking two candidates first or skipping ranks). This complexity disproportionately impacts older voters, non-native English speakers, and lower-income communities.

I was a poll worker at two elections that were RCV.  My station was the scanner, where the voters put their ballots into the voting machine.  The machines spit out ballots that are marked incorrectly - for example, two candidates are marked as second choice.  The voter gets to have a new ballot and vote again.  The old ballot is turned in, torn up, and put into a destroyed ballot envelope.  All in front of the voter.  That didn't happen very often.  But I do suspect that some people's brains are wired so that an RCV ballot is harder for them to figure out.  But my experience is that it was a very small percent of voters. Voters made mistakes under the old system too. 

It would be an interesting study to be at a scanner and try to find common factors among people whose ballot is rejected because they marked the RCV ballot incorrectly.  It would also be tricky to do because of the confidentiality of elections and avoiding intimidating voters.  

Delayed Election Results: Because all ballots must be centralized and fully processed before any elimination round can occur, RCV slows down the reporting process. Late-arriving mail-in or military ballots can delay final results for days or weeks, which erodes public trust in election integrity.

It does take longer to tally votes if no candidate gets a majority in the first round.  But many races only have two candidates in the general election.  The problem, as I understand it, lies with the fact that for the second round, you have to wait for all the absentee ballots to arrive before tabulating the second round percentages.  But that is also a problem with regular voting that is close. 

For this you could do a study to see how many close votes are delayed until all the absentee votes are in for an RCV election and a regular election.  In Alaska you could compare the primary to the general, though we probably get more candidates in the primary than normal because of the open primaries.  Having a president who constantly tells the world that the elections are rigged, does a lot more harm to public confidence than a few dragged out elections  Most voters understand the need to wait for absentee ballots to come in.  

But why does it matter?  As long as the winner is determined before they need to be sworn in, there is no problem except that people are impatient to know who the winner is.  


Increased Costs & System Upgrades: Transitioning to RCV requires expensive updates to voting software, hardware, and extensive public education campaigns funded by taxpayers.

Upgrades - these have already been done.  Changing back to regular elections will cost more if we change back than if we keep what we have.  
Also, with RCV, you don't have the expense of runoff elections as we have in Anchorage mayoral races if no one gets at least 45%.  

*Non-Monotonicity - anyone else unable to explain that?  I did look it up.  Not sure how it applies here  Maybe because the highest vote getter can change from one round to the next when the second and third round votes get added in and the lowest vote getters drop out.  


Saturday, September 12, 2026

Congressional Fisheries Debate Today - Begich and Hill; Sullivan and Peltola

Today, the Congressional Debate on Fisheries took place in Kodiak.  The Governor's debate was Wednesday.  You can watch it here.

The debate is about fish policy.  I include it here because there aren't a lot of chances to see debates between the candidates these days.  Public debates used to be common.  No longer.  

On the video below, first you hear the debate by the House candidates Rep. Begich and Bill Hill.  Then the Senate debate between Sen. Sullivan and Mary Peltola.  I'm not sure why the other two candidates in the race were not there.  Were they not invited?  Did they choose not to attend?  I don't know.  

All four candidates in the governor's race were at that debate Wednesday.  

I have a few reactions to how the candidates did, but I'll give you a chance to view the debate first.

I'd note the Bill Hill came out first and shook hands with the questioners.  Rep. Begich did the same.  Then Bill Hill went over to Rep. Begich and shook hands and spoke to him.  

We first see Sen. Sullivan and Mary Peltola sitting at the table, so I don't know whether they greeted the interviewers and each other, But the body language at the table isn't warm and fuzzy.  



Fisheries might be the least partisan big Alaskan issues.  That makes these debates less revealing, perhaps, than if we had debates that dealt with more controversial issues.  

Thoughts on Begich and Hill debate.  

I was impressed with Begich's manner and knowledge of the issues.  Hill also knew the issues. Hill's answers brought in the view of Alaska Natives and subsistence fishers.  I thought it was telling that when the questioner said a zero percent bi-catch target was unrealistic. That wasn't the question, it was an assumption underlying the question.   Hill's response was that it should be the goal.  Begich agreed.  Would Begich have said that if Hill hadn't first?  I don't know.  Mary Peltola in the second debate said no fishery has zero bi-catch but when bi-catch is in the metric tons, that's a different story.  

Begich said he had written and passed more legislation than any freshman Congressman ever.  Later he gave numbers:  13 bills, nine passed into law.  I'll see if I can find out what they were and how you research the number of bills freshman Congressmen have introduced and passed into law.  

I'd also take issue with Begich's statement that he travels the state and listens and responds to every Alaska.  I don't believe that he has spoken to an open forum in the Anchorage area the whole time he's been in office.  He speaks only to private groups that limit who attends.  These generally are not announced publicly before the event takes place.  I've written a number of letters to his office and I have not received any responses.  

Thoughts on Sullivan and Peltola debate. 

Sullivan was able to tout various bills he had passed that had improved Alaska fisheries.  He contrasted the number of bills he passed to Peltola's no bills passed, without mentioning he has been in the Senate for 12 years, almost half of that time with Trump as president.  Peltola was in Congress for only two years.  

Both candidates knew the topic.  One thing that struck me was Sullivan's tone.  Whiney isn't quite the right word, but he sounded like someone who felt like he had being unfairly attacked  and was exasperatedly trying to defend his record.  Not like a successful and confident two term Senator.  I'd note that Sullivan acknowledged that climate change was one of the factors resulting in fewer fish reaching subsistence fishers.  

But you can judge for yourself.  

Wednesday, September 02, 2026

Alaskan Pols Don't Seem To Believe In Ranked Choice Voting (RCV) [UPDATED]

[I started this over a week ago.  Since then, there's been a lot written about people dropping out of different races, how a couple of politicians have been blocked from running because their disclosures were incomplete.  

My basic message here is that both the Republicans and the Democrats are signaling to the public that they don't have confidence in Ranked Choice Voting (RCV).  Or in voters actually using it.  This is a shame because the Right has put a proposal on the November ballot to abolish RCV.  The Democrats, in three key races - US House and Senate, and Alaska governor's race, have discouraged (apparently more forcefully than that) Democrats from competing with each other in the general election.  To me that indicates distrust in voters being smart enough to actually use RCV to rank the Democrats on the ballot.

From what I can tell, looking at the 2024 US House race, a fair number of voters utilized their RCV option to rank candidates.  But the two extra candidates (besides the main Democrat (Mary Peltola) and the main Republican (Nick Begich) were very marginal candidates - one in prison in New York and the other in the Alaska Independence Party.  My belief is that both the candidates and the public need to learn how to use this process and it's likely the voters are smarter than the politicians think.]


We know the Republicans don't believe in it.  They opposed it strongly from the beginning and they're behind Proposition 2 which would take Alaska back to the old system.  (Prop 2, and this is important, would also get rid of open primaries - their real target - and rules about disclosure of people who contribute to PACs. You can read all 35 pages of Prop.2 here.)

When RCV was first being introduced,  the Democratic leadership opposed Ranked Choice Voting (and the open primaries attached to the initiative), but came around to support RCV.

The biggest benefit of the RCV package that Alaskans passed, would appear to be the bi-partisan majorities in the state House and Senate.  By getting rid of closed primaries, Alaskans prevented parties from electing the most extreme candidates in their party.  With open primaries (vote for one candidate), the top four candidates get to the general election ballot (Ranked Choice - you can vote your first - fourth choices).  It's resulted in more moderate legislators, who are able to work together and pass bills.  At least that seems to be the outcome.  

Our first RCV election - two key Republican candidates (Sarah Palin and Nick Begich) for US House seemed to siphon off votes from each other and Democrat Mary Peltola was elected.  The next round, the top two Republican candidates for the House worked out a deal where Nancy Dahlstrom withdrew, and Nick Begich defeated Mary Peltola.  

This current election (2026) we've seen lots of shenanigans, starting with the GOP controlled Division of Elections leaving candidate Daniel J. Sullivan off the US Senate ballot on the grounds (that exist no where in the law) that he wasn't a real candidate, that he wanted to confuse voters into thinking he was our sitting Senator, Dan S. Sullivan.  

The Alaska Supreme Court required that he be put back on the ballot.  He did reappear, but without a party affiliation (he was a registered Republican) and they added "Incumbent" to the sitting Senator's name (though the regs prohibit any honorifics).

Then voters began getting close to a million dollars worth of flyers and social media ads pushing two out-of-state candidates (yes that's legal) who were identified as progressive and an Alaska Native candidate who is listed as a Democratic Socialist and trashing leading Democratic candidate Mary Peltola.  The strategy, apparently, was to get left leaning candidates on the final ballot to draw votes from Peltola.  

They did get David Leslie (the Alaska Native candidate) on the general election ballot, but Daniel J. Sullivan also made it.  How many of his votes were 'confused with Daniel S" and how many were intentional because of all the publicity he got from the attempts to wipe him off the ballot, we probably will never know. 

So that's the Republican story.  

But the Democrats seem to not believe the voters can handle RCV either.  First, before the primary, Democratic candidate Matt Schultz withdrew from the race, taking the only serious Democratic candidate out of the election.  He says we wasn't getting the party and financial support he needed.  That left Nonpartisan Bill Hill, who got support from the normal liberal support groups - labor unions, the environmental crowd.  

Now Democrat Tom Begich (the uncle of GOP Rep Nick Begich)  has withdrawn from the general election (and the ballot) to support Democrat Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins (JKT).  JKT got 36,961 votes (22.5%) in the primary.  Begich got 34,149 votes (20.8%)  They were the two top vote getters - in the race for governor.  A bunch of Republicans split the GOP vote. The top two - Bernadette Wilson got 16,456 votes (10%) and David Bronson got 13,349 (8%).  With Begich out, that left Republican Treg Taylor to move up to the fourth spot (and the general election ballot.)  But he was disqualified for not filling in the financial disclosure info when he signed up to be a candidate.  Then his Lt. Gov candidate moved up to be the governor candidate and chose Treg Taylor's wife to be her running mate.   Though she may have the same disclosure problems her husband has. 

I'm hearing complaints from people I know, and I feel it myself, that these politicians don't trust Alaskan voters to rank the candidates.  

They don't trust the voters to rank their preferred Democrat first and the other one second.  

With two strong Democrats running for governor, it was a chance to demonstrate how RCV should work.  Each should have strongly told their supporters to vote for them first and the other Democrat second.  Emphasized that they were very similar on policy issues.  This would have been especially important this year because we also vote on whether to end RCV (and I feel compelled to always point out we would also end open primaries and disclosure of those who give dark money.  And other things are in there, like having Governor and Lt. Governor run separately, not as a team.)

Tom Begich sent a letter out to supporters that justified getting out of the race as a matter of money:

"At a time when so many Alaskans are already stretched thin, we cannot keep asking them to give more and more just to compete with much larger amounts of money flowing into politics in Alaska. Continuing through November would require millions more, and we believe that the strongest path to victory is to bring Democratic voters, donors and resources together behind one candidate.

Before we made this decision, I spoke directly with Jonathan about the priorities at the heart of our campaign and the promises we made to Alaskans.

We share a commitment to strong public schools, affordable energy, housing and health care, and making sure Alaska receives its fair share from our resources."

But it's clear both parties are wary of having more than one candidate from their party running for the same office.  The Republicans did everything they could to push the candidacies of marginal Democratic candidates onto the US Senate race.  At this point that seems to have failed.  Right now we have Peltola (the Democrat who got 49.5% of the vote in the primary) and three Republicans - the current US Senator Dan S. Sullivan, Daniel J. Sullivan, and Jerry Heikes.   [I'd note that today the Anchorage Daily News said that Democrat David Leslie has dropped out of the race under pressure from Democrats, and that Jerry Heikes, listed as a Republican, has moved up to the fourth spot.] 

And right now, there is one Democrat and three Republicans running for Governor.  (The deadline to drop out has passed, but there are questions about Jodi Taylor's financial disclosure which is pretty much the same as her husband's was.)    [UPDATE 9/9/2026:  Treg Taylor is back on the ballot on orders apparently from the Lt. Governor's (the same Nancy Dahlstrom from 2024) superiors because, they say, lots of people have left things blank and not been disqualified.]

I'd also note that Candi English (Treg Taylor's running mate) moving up as a governor candidate raises new questions.  She's been relatively invisible and it seems odd for her to leapfrog over other candidates onto the general ballot.   

There is no perfect system.  Whatever system you have, people figure out ways to game the system.  Ideally, we will not get rid of Ranked Choice Voting in November and we can learn how to make it work.

As I looked back on the 2024 US House race, there were four candidates:

  • Mary Peltola
  • Nick Begich
  • Eric Hafner (who was then and is now a prisoner in a New York prison and labeled as a Democrat)
  • John Wayne Howe (Alaska Independence Party)

This is a disparate group of candidates.  You can't judge RCV based on whether voters in this race chose to use more than one vote or not.  Why would a serious voter cast a vote for someone in prison across the country?  Possibly as protest.  But then why cast a second vote?

Peltola voters have no reason to cast a second vote.  What would be the point?  

But, in fact, people did cast second votes.  The first person eliminated was Eric Hafner.  

The charts come from the Alaska Division of Elections page here.


Hafner got 3558 votes.  The Hafner voters gave 267 to Nick Begich, 661 to John Wayne Howe, and 1313 to Mary Peltola.  That totals 2214 second place votes transferred to other candidates.  62% of the people who voted for Hafner ranked a second candidate.  That seems to be a fair number.  (I understand exhausted on the chart to mean that there wasn't a second choice vote.  Overvotes, I think means they marked more than one person for the same ranking.  [I called the Division of Elections in Anchorage to check.  They referred me to the main office in Juneau.  The guy who answered the phone had to go ask someone else.  But eventually he confirmed that my guesses were correct.  I also asked about the Fraction column and he had to go ask again.  Apparently for some jurisdictions the votes can be divided into fractions, but Alaska doesn't do that so these are whole votes, or 1.]

John Wayne Howe got 13,871 votes and 7541 of his voters (or 54%) ranked someone second.  

Given that Eric Hafner and John Wayne Howe voters were probably disaffected voters who chose a) a New York prisoner and b) and Alaska Independence Party candidate as their first choice, these seem like fairly high percentages of voters using RCV.  

If there were two strong candidates from the same party with very similar policy positions on the general ballot, I'd guess there would be a higher percentage of second place votes.  It's true that the first time around (2022), Sarah Palin and Nick Begich (both Republicans) attacked each other instead of working together.  In 2024 the second place 'name' Republican, Nancy Dahlstrom, dropped out rather than run against Nick Begich.  

But we won't see two such candidates from the Democratic side in state wide office elections this year.  We will see that with Republicans in the Governor's race, but not really in the US Senate race.  There we have one Democrat (Peltola), one main Republican (Sen, Sullivan), and two lesser Republicans.  The three Republicans are not likely to cooperate and tell the voters to rank the other two Republicans. But the 2024 numbers suggest that the most voters will rank a second choice. 

The US House race was the only statewide election in 2024 except for the presidential election.  I'm guessing the presidential election could have been RCV, but in any case Trump won a majority so if it was RCV, there was no need to go to the RCV round,  

My biggest concern here is that the politicians aren't going to let us actually use ranked choice voting because if they have two main candidates competing, they'll pull the one with fewer votes out.  The three Republicans on the ballot for governor are an exception to the  trend I'm calling out here.  Let's see if they cooperate and tell voters to give their second and third place votes the other Republicans.

[This is not as succinct (or probably as clear) as I wanted this to be, but I need to move on.]


[UPDATE: September 24, 2026:  I've responded to the anonymous commenter here.]









Thursday, August 20, 2026

Heikes Would Ship Illegal Alien Criminals to Guantanamo Bay To Be Tried and Killed

I really want to do a post on Ranked Choice Voting and how candidates seem to not trust voters to actually use RCV the way it was intended.  But I got a bit side-tracked by Gerald Heikes' 5th place finish.  But it turns out to fit right in to what I want to write about RCV.  So let's leave it here as background for that future post.  (Not too far in the future I hope.)

With less than 1% of votes yet to be counted Gerald Heikes is in 5th place in the US Senate race, 19 votes behind the 4th place candidate David Leslie.  Leslie is listed as a Democrat who listed no funding or campaigning, but was heavily promoted by an Outside conservative PAC.  The top four candidates will be on the general election ranked choice ballot. (Unless they withdraw, in which case the next highest vote getter moves up.)  I'd note, there appear to be about 900 votes left to count.  

The Alaska Beacon (August 12, 2026) said 

"Of Right For Alaska’s $1.2 million in spending through Aug. 7, nearly $574,000 went to oppose Sullivan with $410,000 backing Republican Gerald Heikes and nearly $219,000 to support Earl “Skip” Southworth of the Alaskan Party – the successor to the right-leaning Alaskan Independence Party. An Earl Southworth of Dutch Harbor, Alaska, donated to Democratic nominee Kamala Harris’ presidential campaign in 2024 and to Democratic state Sen. Forrest Dunbar a decade earlier, FEC records show. OpenSecrets reached out to Heikes and Southworth but did not immediately receive responses from either." (emphasis added)

Below is from a 2020 interview when Gerald Heikes was running for the US House against Don Young.  It's worth reading his positions

From KTVF, Fairbanks (includes video):

Photo from Ballot Ready

"Published: Aug. 7, 2020 at 4:10 PM AKDT

FAIRBANKS, Alaska (KTVF) -


Republican Gerald “Jer” Heikes is running to represent Alaska in the U.S. House of Representatives. This seat is currently occupied by Don Young.

He said he is running because what he sees in Congress “doesn’t fit the narrative for anybody being truthful and honest.”

“I see every politician up there grandstand[ing] for some reason, then they lie about anything and everything to get what they want. That’s something I cannot do, is be able to lie or compromise because I’m a born-again Christian, which makes me a perfect target for the left, and lying is not part of life. If you can’t be truthful about what you’re doing and be honest in your opinions and what you have to say, then the deception won’t work for you as a human being going through life.”

According to Heikes, if he gets to Washington, there are things on the floor of the House that he would love to talk about. “This started out as a godly nation. Now we’re an ungodly nation, and everybody’s pointing fingers and they’re backbiting like little children and squabbling and they’re putting on shows and antics because of the camera. But they’re actually hiding their true selves in the lies that they’re putting forth.”

Heikes said he’d like to make Alaska a place where children can grow up and be safe. “We can have laws that protect us from illegal aliens -- that if you’re an American citizen and you’re attacked, or something happens to you and your family because of an illegal alien, they are shipped out of the country to like Guantanamo Bay. We’ll have like a three-judge military panel try them. And if they caused harm enough or they murder an American citizen, then they’ll be immediately sentenced to death, taken out in the back of the courthouse and done in. And there should be a cremation facility there, because there’ll be a lot of people going there.”

He added, “If they find that they are not worthy of death, then they’re deported back to their home country; but if they are found back in America illegally, then they go back and face the death penalty again and from the same three-judge court.”

Heikes would also like to see a federal loan for road-building in Alaska. “We need to build roads in Alaska. We need to build roads from Fairbanks to Nome, to Bethel, to branch out like that and fill in the blanks,” he said, adding, “A lot of people outside don’t realize that half the stuff is either flown in or barged into Alaska, and we need a decent roadway system that spans the whole state.”

He said, “From the first of January to the first of May, 9,900,000 babies were aborted worldwide. And since the COVID thing came on, there’s 150,000 deaths due to former ailments that people have and things of that nature. We spent trillions of dollars, yet we murder, at an unprecedented rate, the unborn. That has to stop.”

Heikes is running against John Nelson and Don Young on the Republican Primary Ballot on August 18th."


Here's (a bit of) what the Anchorage Daily News said about Heikes in 2024:

"Gerald Heikes, a Palmer resident and perennial candidate for public office in Alaska, has no money to spend on building a campaign website or advertising his positions. But a Democrat-backed group is spending hundreds of thousands of dollars highlighting Heikes’ anti-abortion stance in a quest to bolster Democratic incumbent Rep. Mary Peltola’s chances at reelection."  (emphasis added)

I've got more to say about the Alaska US Senate race and ranked-choice voting strategies in general.  Meanwhile, let's get this up so people know who this candidate is.  He still has a chance to be on the November ballot."

Here's the vote count as of August 20, 2026 1pm:



Tuesday, August 18, 2026

One Very Clear Winner - Prop 1 - Alaskans Want Spending Limits

 



For other election results, click here.  Just refresh the page to see if there are updates.  


I'd note Kreis-Tomkins is leading in the governor's race,  with Tom Begich, though the combined Republican numbers are formidable.  Peltola is slightly ahead of Sullivan, with Daniel J. Sullivan a distant third.  

But these are early numbers.  Only Ballot Measure one, to reinstate campaign finance limits is clearly going to win.  And some state legislative races with only one candidate.  A few others look conclusive, but the top four candidates move to the general election.  

Monday, August 17, 2026

Primary Election Day Tomorrow in Alaska and Prediction Markets

 Hard to believe it's finally here.  We didn't get any campaign literature in the mail today!!!

Probably the most uncertainty centers around the Governor's race.  There are lots of known candidates.  Which of the Republicans will end up in the top four?  And will other Republicans drop out in the belief that being on the ballot could siphon off votes from the top Republican and help the top Democrat.  Will the second Democrat, if there is one, also drop out?  

Ranked Choice Tabulation Questions

Given that we have Ranked Choice Voting, voters can rank all four candidates - first choice, second choice, third choice, fourth choice. If a candidate gets 50%+1 vote in the first round that candidate wins.   If no one gets over 50%, the candidate with the fewest first place votes is dropped and that candidate's second place votes are distributed to the other candidates.

DOE_Tabulation_60sec_HULU.mp4  Link to the video explaining how they count ranked choice voting from the Division of Elections.  Couldn't find a way to embed the video here.  [I did look, and it can be done, but I didn't find instructions I could use.)

I have questions about tabulating the votes, but tomorrow is election day and I'm not going to try to get answers from the Division of Elections until after the election. 

The video doesn't explain how, if ever, the third and fourth choice votes would count.  Perhaps if someone's choice for a second place vote has already been eliminated, the third place vote would count.  (I couldn't find anything that actually says that.)  And with only four candidates in the general, I don't think you would ever get to the fourth choice vote.  

Also, what if someone got no first place votes, but was the second place choice for all the other candidates?  That person would be eliminated on the first round and would never get the second place votes.  It's not a likely scenario, but something like that could happen.  


Ranked Choice Strategy Questions

In 2022, Sarah Palin and Nick Begich split the Republican vote in the general and enough second place votes gave Peltola the win.  

In 2024, two Republicans pulled out of the general, presumably because they didn't want to do the same thing, and Nick Begich beat Peltola.  But that year Trump was also on the ballot and that brought out lots of Republican voters.  (Total votes for US House:  2024 = 329,493;  2022=263,610) 

Ranked Choice Voting is supposed to overcome this sort of problem by giving voters the option to make second and third choice votes.  But not enough voters have done that.  Will they learn to do that in the future?  Are there good strategic reasons not to rank?  What are they?  Will there be candidates who urge their voters to choose Candidate B as their second choice?

The Spoiler Candidates and the Spoiler PAC Campaigns

My previous post was about Outside [Alaska lingo for outside of Alaska] PACs spending lots of money on fringe candidates - one from Arizona, one from South Dakota, and one Alaskan - in an attempt to get them onto the final four in the general.  

One of those candidates - Richard Grayson - has said he would withdraw if he were in the final four.  Today Grayson emailed me a link to a review of what the prediction markets are saying about the Alaska US Senate race.  There's a lot more discussion at the link, but here's the gist:




That's hard to read 

That was too small, and now it's too big, but the chart is in the link.  I've also looked at the Kalshi page on this race and it's clear I need to learn a lot more about prediction markets and what everything means.  I do suspect that a lot of people who are betting are not from Alaska and don't really know that much about our elections.  But I don't really know.  

The prediction markets didn't do that well in Michigan and Wisconsin.

In comparison, on June 23, 2026  I wrote:

"At this point, I''d guess that Peltola, Sen. Sullivan, and Kohlhaas* would be the top three, scooping up most of the votes.  As I look at the 2024 House race, the others won't get many votes.  Though I suspect Dustin Darden has run often enough that people will vote for him because they recognize his name.  And Daniel J. probably has a good chance to get votes too, for the very reasons the Sen. Sullivan campaign and the Republican Party of Alaska and the National Party want him off the ticket.  It would be between him and Darden for fourth place.  

Given that early polls show Peltola ahead of Sen. Sullivan, having Daniel J. on the November ballot would be a threat to Sen. Sullivan's reelection.  If Daniel J. made it to the general election, and there he pulled 5% of the vote from the Senator, it could easily be enough to give Peltola the victory.  Some might say that Peltola's ahead now, so she'd win either way.  I think that's counting your chicks before the eggs are laid.  

[*I'd mentioned Kohlhaas in an earlier paragraph as another candidate (Alaska Libertarian Party) who had run often enough that people knew his name."]

Tomorrow evening, and surely by Wednesday, we'll know.   

[This post has more of a deadline than most, so I'm going to post now without proofing as much as I normally would.  If I find typos etc., I'll fix them.  I won't change content, but if I do, like always,  I'll make it clear what I did.]