I guess this is a film festival post because I'm starting with a film I saw the other night - Paper Spiders.
In the film a widow lives with her about-to-go-to-college daughter. Her husband, a doctor, has been dead two or three years. New neighbors move in and the mother gets upset because she sees him,
|
Screen shot from Paper Spiders |
through the window, back into a tree on her lawn.
She runs out and comes back to tell her daughter that he told her to fuck off.
The mom later says the neighbor is throwing rocks at their house. One night she's sure he's on the roof. The daughter goes next door to just talk to the guy and the wife yells at her. "Talk to her? He can't come within ten feet of her. Your mother put out a restraining order against him. Your mother is deeply disturbed."
Mom knows he's an electrical engineer and she's sure he's sending some kind of waves at her that are giving her headaches. Whatever explanation the daughter gives, the mom twists it around saying "that proves what I'm saying."
"He's trying to torture me, it's a power struggle, can't you see?"
The daughter, Melanie, tells her mom her grades are dropping and the school counselor wants to do family therapy. The mom quickly starts talking about the "stalker" and the counselor pulls out the DSM and reads her about delusional disorder (my definition comes from The Cleveland Clinic)
"What is delusional disorder?
Delusional disorder, previously called paranoid disorder, is a type of serious mental illness — called a “psychosis”— in which a person cannot tell what is real from what is imagined. The main feature of this disorder is the presence of delusions, which are unshakable beliefs in something untrue. People with delusional disorder experience non-bizarre delusions, which involve situations that could occur in real life, such as being followed, poisoned, deceived, conspired against, or loved from a distance. These delusions usually involve the misinterpretation of perceptions or experiences. In reality, however, the situations are either not true at all or highly exaggerated."
The counselor asks if the mother recognizes any of the symptoms. The mom's response: "I think you nailed it. He has delusional disorder."
Mom hires a private detective to track the man's movements.
They meet the detective for the final report. The detective chronicles the neighbor's movements. On Saturday he went to St Percy's hospital.
- Mom: "You see, he's getting psychiatric treatment."
- Detective: "I've been in the business for 25 years, so if there was any suspecious activity, I assure you, I would catch it."
- Mom: "You understand what this means. We're dealing with a seasoned criminal who can out maneuver a seasoned investigator with 25 years experience."
Things get worse and worse and eventually the mom moves out so the neighbor can't persecute her and sleeps in the car to stay safe from the neighbor.
As we all watch Donald Trump claim that Biden stole the election, this delusional woman comes to mind. She's certain about the neighbor. Every shred of evidence offered to disprove the neighbor's evil mission is turned around as further proof of his devious cleverness. And Trump ignores the fact that many of the judges turning down his appeals are judges he appointed! And he doesn't have quite the agility the mom in the movie had to turn around such facts to her advantage. He just changes the subject or blames the messenger.
Part of me believes that Trump knows exactly what he's doing, but his behavior is so, so similar to this character's, perhaps he doesn't.
If Trump weren't president of the United States, a normal family would get him treatment. Or at least try to prevent him from destroying their lives. Given the power/money dynamics of the Trump family I suspect he might not be challenged, even if the kids saw their inheritance being frittered away. (I don't know whether his assets are greater than his debts.)
And even in the movie, the daughter had a really difficult time getting her mom treatment. She was homeless first and then involuntarily admitted only after a very public incident where she turned on her daughter for not supporting her.
How many of Trump's supporters also have delusional disorder? Probably not that many. After all, their news sources all support this mass delusion. The mom had no one supporting her delusions.
Here's what the Cleveland Clinic says about treatment:
"How is delusional disorder treated?
Treatment for delusional disorder most often includes medication and psychotherapy (a type of counseling); however, delusional disorder is highly resistant to treatment with medication alone. People with severe symptoms or who are at risk of hurting themselves or others might need to be in the hospital until the condition is stabilized."
The mom was given medication and was in the hospital two weeks. Even then, at the end she marches off to confront the neighbor again only to be told he's been dead for a month. But the mom says that's bullshit and points at some equipment in the hallway to prove it's the machine he's been using to torture her. The neighbor looks and says, "That's his chemo machine."
I don't think any of Trump's destructivenes will end on January 20th. There are too many people who share Trump's delusions, not just about the election, but about every thing else. Trump supporters are talking about overturning the election still.
The Texas lawsuit asked the Supreme Court to throw out hundreds of thousands of ballots. Over 100 House Republicans joined the lawsuit. And even after the Supreme Court (including three of Trump's appointees) voted 9-2 against Trump of procedural grounds and 9-0 on substance, Law&Crime notes:
"In response [to the Supreme Court decision], Texas GOP Chairman Allen West on Friday erroneously claimed that the high court’s ruling—which was widely expected among legal experts and court watchers—created a precedent that allows states to act unlawfully in the administration of elections, leading him to float the idea that the Lone Star State should look into forming a separate nation. In other words, he is preaching secession."
And Trump is inciting his followers by insisting that he actually won the election and that Biden stole it with fraudulent votes.
At some point, the Democrats are going to have to play hardball.
"18 U.S. Code § 2384. Seditious conspiracy
If two or more persons in any State or Territory, or in any place subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, conspire to overthrow, put down, or to destroy by force the Government of the United States, or to levy war against them, or to oppose by force the authority thereof, or by force to prevent, hinder, or delay the execution of any law of the United States, or by force to seize, take, or possess any property of the United States contrary to the authority thereof, they shall each be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than twenty years, or both."
You can see that this discussion could go on and on. Gore and Kerry conceded their elections even though there was much more evidence than Trump has that they won. Even Lincoln wanted to welcome the South back into the union to make that return more cordial. But that resulted in another 100 years of de facto slavery and inequality for blacks. (See for example White Rage by Carol Anderson.) It seems to me the extreme behavior of Trump requires serious consequences lest these new excesses become the norm.