I talked to someone who is strongly anti-Trump the other day and he was also adamant about replacing Biden as the Democratic candidate.
My gut says this is exactly what the Trump camp (including Putin and other foreign disrupters, Federalist Society, Heritage Society, etc.) would like to see.
By focusing on one speck in Biden's career and presidency, Trump's team has gotten the attention off Trump's conviction, looming court cases, damning mentions in the newly released Epstein court documents, history of fraud and bankruptcies) and is moving the spotlight back to Biden's age and competence. Really?!!! And causing infighting among Democrats.
But I want to emphasize that all this is happening - not in isolation - but in a dynamic system of vested interests, laws, organizations, individuals, agencies, money. And this is not limited to the US. Players from around the world are involved.
To capture some of that I've created a grossly simplified graphic of some of the factors that are in play.
Replacing Biden would set up the Democrats for a series new crises down the line. Once it happened, they'd then have to choose a replacement. The natural candidate is Vice President Kamala Harris. But people will say that a Black, South Asian/American, woman would destroy Democratic chances. Others will say, not picking her would cause the most consistent supporters of Democrats - Black Americans - to sit out the election. One of the most articulate people in Biden's cabinet is Pete Buttigieg, but the naysayers will say a gay candidate would lose the Independents. [None of these alarms is necessarily true.]
Meanwhile, the Heritage Foundation is already planning court challenges to putting any replacement on state ballots. If successful in a couple of blue and purple states, Trump would win.
There will be new scrutiny on the new candidate (and eventually vice presidential candidate). It used to be the opposition would need to find some past scandal, but nowadays they just make it up. Biden's worst scandals - his age, his son - have already been disclosed.
Are Putin bots and FSB (the main successor of the KGB) agents working hard to elect Trump by throwing Democrats into disarray? You better believe it. They played a role in various European elections including Brexit.
No one should be surprised at attempts to impact foreign elections. This is standard operating procedure for the big powers intelligence agencies. The CIA did (probably still is) that regularly.
Putin's original career was in the KGB. He's fully aware of this and how to do it. And he's been playing this game a long time.
It's true, though. Biden looked and sounded terrible. I've seen a Spout that said the CNN lighting and sound technicians did Biden no favors, but I haven't seen any evidence.
And at 81 he has to be slowing down somewhat. The presidency has aged every president faster. But Biden has half a century of experience in Washington - as Senator, as Vice President, and as President. He has relationships with many, many members of Congress and world leaders and his experience has led to wisdom about how to get things done, as shown by his astounding record of accomplishments. with a slim margin of votes in Congress.
What if he works just four hours a day? He would still be putting in more work than Trump apparently did while president.
While the president is the figure head of the administration, we are actually electing a team. Biden has put together a powerful team.
The Brookings Institute created a graph to represent the turnovers in the Trump's "A Team" and cabinet" compared to past presidents. They did the same for the Biden administration.
This election is about Democracy versus Fascism. A slowing Biden would still be a better president than a vigorous Trump. And we have one debate - a speck in time - that raises questions about whether Biden is getting too old, versus 3+ years of competent performance and post debate appearances that show a man with his full mental capabilities. This man, who has overcome a stutter as a kid, has never been a great public speaker. But he knows the issues and his claims are based on facts.
It's a terrible indictment of - I'm not sure what, probably a little of everything - US education, capitalist values of greed, including corporate news media, political manipulation (gerrymandering, voter suppression), racism, sexism, religion, that Trump is even a contender. That the media and Republicans are calling for him to step down.
Biden has an array of great debaters in his party who can get out there and campaign for him if he needs to shorten his daily schedule.
My friend who told me the other day that Biden should resign, said that if Biden runs and wins, he'll come and tell me he was wrong.
But he didn't say what he'd do if Biden steps down and his replacement loses. Because I think losing in that scenario that is the more likely outcome. Because changing candidates mid campaign will lead to lots of dissension, disruption, and lost momentum.
Of course I could be wrong. Biden could quickly slide into dementia. Or a dynamic Kamala Harris could ride to victory. Anything could happen in the months ahead. But right now, as I see it, keeping Biden is the wisest path to not only stopping Trump, but to turning this country around and reversing much of the damage the first Trump administration has cause.
This is going to be one of the nastiest elections ever, with misinformation drowning out truth, and devious schemes to disenfranchise voters and throw elections. Double and triple check any claims made by anybody. The LIE machine has been put on high.