Ikiru v. Comedy of Power

Comedy of Power at the Museum last night was disappointing. Here's an excerpt from the blurb:

COMEDY OF POWER is inspired by the real-life story of examining magistrate Eva Joly, whose seven-year investigation into charges of fraud and bribery at the French oil company Elf Aquitaine was described by The Guardian as "the biggest and most scandalous fraud inquiry in Europe since the Second World War.

Tonight we went to the Bear Tooth and had no idea what we were going to see, only that it was Monday night Foreign/Art film night. After the first minute I realized we'd seen this 1952 Akira Kurosawa classic on DVD at home.

The black and white Ikiru showed us a bureaucrat who spent 30 years of his life stamping documents and as a cog in the system who maintains his job by doing nothing. When he learns he has up to six months to live, he realizes he hasn't lived, and with the help of a few strangers, figures out what he needs to do. In 2 1/2 hours we go through questions about the meaning of life, an analysis of the post War Japanese bureaucracy, come to understand this man who as his last act, fights the bureaucracy he's been part of to help some neighborhood women build a park.

Comedy of Power in contrast squandered its two hours leaving us wondering how did this investigator manage to pull off whatever it was she pulled off (it was never quite clear what got accomplished.) We really didn't learn much about any of the characters or what was going on. How could a one woman office with an assistant who we learn at the end was a spy do all the work needed to bring down giant corporate executives working closely with politicians - including her boss? After spending a week at the Anderson trial here, I know that just that relative small case took a lot of people to gather and organize all the data.


But Ikiru I highly recommend. Its story about human beings is timeless and one everyone should read now and then.